Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eileen Slifer's avatar

Nice piece, caught my attention last night with the email notification and makes me more anxious to make time soon to read chapter 4 in your book.

As an artist even this blog piece prompted so many thoughts about the metaphor of the Church (and us as individuals) being God's artwork!

You mentioned the difference between bad art and good art. While I suppose that is subjective and in my experience there are certainly many people who like or settle for what I would consider bad art, probably for a variety of reasons including the fact that good art comes at a high cost, in general I think the average person could pretty much be in agreement in judging bad art from good art and all the spectrum from fair to mediocre to outstanding.

As I am working on a painting this morning and thinking about this piece of writing, too many particular things come into my mind to simply comment :)

If I were to pick just one thing that in my view helps me identify a piece of bad art handled by an untrained person within the first 30 seconds of looking at a visual work, it would be their handling of values.

Meaning their handling of the spectrum of darks and lights and their understanding of color theory.

There's a lot I could say about this in terms of metaphor, and practice. But I will pause here at least for the moment!

Expand full comment
Eileen Slifer's avatar

Nice piece, caught my attention last night with the email notification and makes me more anxious to make time soon to read chapter 4 in your book.

As an artist even this blog piece prompted so many thoughts about the metaphor of the Church (and us as individuals) being God's artwork!

You mentioned the difference between bad art and good art. While I suppose that is subjective and in my experience there are certainly many people who like or settle for what I would consider bad art, probably for a variety of reasons including the fact that good art comes at a high cost, in general I think the average person could pretty much be in agreement in judging bad art from good art and all the spectrum from fair to mediocre to outstanding.

As I am working on a painting this morning and thinking about this piece of writing, too many particular things come into my mind to simply comment :)

If I were to pick just one thing that in my view helps me identify a piece of bad art handled by an untrained person within the first 30 seconds of looking at a visual work, it would be their handling of values.

Meaning their handling of the spectrum of darks and lights and their understanding of color theory.

There's a lot I could say about this in terms of metaphor, and practice. But I will pause here at least for the moment!

Expand full comment

No posts